On this page 8
- Where open-box pays, and where it doesn’t
- Graphics cards: 3% off is not a discount
- Headphones and earbuds: where open-box pays
- TVs: 8% off is the ordinary open-box price
- Open-box, refurbished or used? Depends on what you’re buying
- Check the new price before you buy not-new
- The half-price refurbished CPU
- Black Friday rules, category by category
Buy an open-box graphics card at Best Buy and you’ll typically save 3%. Three percent, for a box somebody else opened. So we went looking for where not-new is a real deal and where it’s a dented box at nearly full price. We checked 1,500 open-box, refurbished and used offers against the cheapest new price for the same item at any store we track. Open-box headphones and earbuds were about 23% cheaper than new. TVs, 12%. Graphics cards, 3%. And for about half of Best Buy’s open-box offers, another store sold the same thing new for less.
Where open-box pays, and where it doesn’t
One rule for everything below: the discount is always against the cheapest new price for the same item at any store we track, not the same store’s crossed-out price. And we only count products that at least two stores still sell new, so that new price is a real one.
below the cheapest new price of the same product
Dot: the typical offer. Bar: the middle half of offers. 92% of these open-box offers are Best Buy's. US, 30 days to Nov 20, 2026.
Four groups fall out of it. Headphones and earbuds are where open-box pays, at 23% cheaper than new. Tablets, TVs and monitors come in at 11% to 13% cheaper; lenses, laptops and cameras at 7% to 9%. Graphics cards are a category of their own, at 3%.
Most open-box headphones were at least 13% cheaper than new. For earbuds, tablets and TVs, most were at least 7% to 8% cheaper. So an open-box pair of headphones at 10% off is pricey by open-box standards, and an open-box TV at 8% off is the normal price, not a deal.
Graphics cards: 3% off is not a discount
Most Best Buy open-box graphics cards were around 3% off. That’s Best Buy’s standard markdown for a card in Excellent condition, and every card here was Excellent. A couple of cards had bigger discounts, 8% and 16%. Surprisingly, a couple of open-box cards were more expensive than new offers, so remember to always check.
New card prices have climbed all autumn (our GPU price guide has been following them), and with new stock scarce, a store has no reason to mark a returned card down much.
ASUS GeForce RTX 5070 PRIME OC 12GB GDDR7 Black
Over the 30 days to November 20, Best Buy’s open-box price for this card was 3% cheaper than the cheapest new price (also Best Buy’s). The card shows today’s prices.
Fiche complète : specs, historique de prix et avis →Older cards look different only because their “new” price is fiction. Across all graphics cards, refurbished ones were 28% cheaper than new. But most of those cards are sold by marketplace sellers, who often inflate prices. If you can get one from a reputable store directly, you can usually get it cheaper and maybe even find a decent deal. Otherwise, skip it and choose a different GPU.
An open-box graphics card at 3% off is a new card with a used box.
Headphones and earbuds: where open-box pays
Headphones were the steadiest category we have: the typical open-box pair was 23% cheaper than new, and refurbished pairs were about the same (24%). With headphones, the condition label matters less than the price.
Sonos Ace Ultra
Sonos’s Ace Ultra is the typical case: over the 30 days to November 20, its cheapest open-box offer was 23% cheaper than the cheapest new price. The card shows today’s prices.
Fiche complète : specs, historique de prix et avis →Earbuds were 23% cheaper open-box too; refurbished earbuds, only 16%. Nobody wants someone else’s earbuds in their ears, and the open-box price shows it: where the same earbuds were sold both ways, open-box was usually the cheaper one. The spread is wide, though: one open-box offer in eight cost as much as new or more.
TVs: 8% off is the ordinary open-box price
TVs sit mid-pack: the typical open-box TV was 12% cheaper than the cheapest new price. The most common discount was 8%, and that’s no accident: it’s Best Buy’s standard markdown for an Excellent-grade open-box TV. None cost as much as new, and about a third were 20% or more off.
One thing you won’t find here: Best Buy’s store-only open-box TVs, mostly its Good and Fair grades. You can’t buy them online and we can’t check a store shelf, so they’re left out.
Samsung S90H QN48S90HAEXZA 48"
Samsung’s 48-inch S90H OLED is the common case: over the 30 days to November 20, Best Buy’s open-box price was 8% cheaper than the cheapest new price (also Best Buy’s). The card shows today’s prices.
Fiche complète : specs, historique de prix et avis →Open-box, refurbished or used? Depends on what you’re buying
Open-box is the most common kind of not-new offer. It is not always the cheapest kind.
below the cheapest new price of the same product
Dot: the typical offer. Bar: the middle half of offers. Products at least two stores still sell new. US, 30 days to Nov 20, 2026.
Lenses: buy used, not open-box. Used lenses, most of them from camera stores, were 23% cheaper than new; open-box lenses, 9%. Where the same lens was sold both ways, used was cheaper four times in five. A lens has no battery to wear out, and most faults show up in a few test shots, so a graded used copy from a store that takes returns is a small risk.
Sony E 16-55mm f/2.8 G APS-C
Sony’s 16-55mm f/2.8 G shows the gap. Over the 30 days to November 20, a used copy at a camera store was a third cheaper than the cheapest new price; the open-box one, 4%. The card shows today’s prices.
Fiche complète : specs, historique de prix et avis →Tablets: refurbished first. Refurbished tablets were 25% cheaper than new, open-box 13%, and not one refurbished tablet cost as much as new. iPads follow the same pattern.
Monitors: refurbished first too. Earbuds: open-box first, as above. Headphones: either. Cameras hold their value whichever way you buy, at 7% to 10% cheaper than new. The table at the end has every figure.
Check the new price before you buy not-new
About one refurbished offer in eight cost as much as the cheapest new price or more; for open-box it was about one in eleven. Cameras were the weak spot: one open-box camera in six cost as much as new or more, and laptops weren’t far behind.
The reason is usually boring: the cheapest new price is at another store. For about half of Best Buy’s open-box offers, another store sold the same item new for less. And most of the open-box offers that cost as much as new were Best Buy units priced below Best Buy’s own new price, just not below somebody else’s.
Apple AirPods Pro 3rd Generation
AirPods Pro 3, over the 30 days to November 20: the cheapest open-box pair cost 6.5% more than the cheapest new price, while a refurbished pair was 16% cheaper. The card shows today’s prices.
Fiche complète : specs, historique de prix et avis →Open-box is a discount on one store’s price, not on the market’s.
The half-price refurbished CPU
Count every product, old ones included, and refurbished processors look like the bargain of the year: typically 52% cheaper than new. They aren’t. Most of those chips are Intel Core and Xeon parts several generations old that only one store still sells new, nearly always a marketplace seller. A 2015 Core i7-6700 was $47 refurbished against a $261 “new” listing: a huge “discount” on a price nobody pays for a chip from 2015.
The rule carries over to anything old. If only one store sells a product new, ignore the discount and compare the refurbished price with what you’d buy instead today.
Black Friday rules, category by category
| Category | Buy | Open-box, cheaper than new by | Refurbished or used, cheaper than new by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headphones | Open-box or refurbished | 23% | 24% |
| Earbuds | Open-box | 23% | 16% |
| TVs | Open-box | 12% | - |
| Tablets | Refurbished | 13% | 25% |
| Monitors | Refurbished | 11% | 19% |
| Camera lenses | Used, from a store that grades them | 9% | 23% (used) |
| Cameras | Either, after checking the new price | 7% | 10% |
| Laptops | Open-box, after checking the new price | 7% | - |
| Graphics cards | New | 3% | - |
How much cheaper than the cheapest new price the typical offer was. US, 30 days to November 20, 2026. Dash: fewer than 20 offers.
Got an offer in front of you? Type it in. The checker shows how it compares with the same kind of offer in our data.
Use the cheapest new price at any store, not the same store's. Band: the middle half of offers we tracked; dot: the typical one.
Every PriceZen product page lists open-box and refurbished offers next to the new ones, so the cheapest new price is one look away. And if you’re wondering whether this week’s new prices are real discounts in the first place, see our fake-discount check.
How we measured, and what this doesn’t cover
- The comparison. For every product with a not-new offer, we took its cheapest open-box, refurbished or used offer, priced at its typical price over the 30 days to November 20, 2026, and set it against the cheapest new offer of the same product, in the same configuration, at any store we track. That gave 1,491 pairs on 1,344 products; the article rounds to 1,500. “Typical” and “typically” mean the median: line the offers up and take the one in the middle.
- Offers and prices. An offer is one store’s item in one condition; Amazon Renewed counts as refurbished. Its price is the median of its daily closing prices in the window, on days it was priced and not shown as unavailable. Shipping, coupons, card offers and member-only prices are not included.
- Pairs. For each US product and each not-new condition, the pair takes the not-new offer with the lowest such price that has a comparable new offer, and sets it against the comparable new offer with the lowest price. Comparable means the two listing titles state no conflicting storage, memory, screen size or lens mount, and the new listing does not say “used”. So the new price is the cheapest new offer’s typical price over the whole window, not a same-day price: read “12% cheaper” as typical prices over the month, not a saving on a given day. Single units only, one pair per product and condition.
- Grades. Best Buy sells almost only its Excellent grade online. Good and Fair units are in store only and are left out, so Best Buy’s open-box figures here are Excellent units (350 of 354, every TV and graphics card).
- Products still sold new. Charts and category figures use the 675 pairs (575 products) that two or more store chains sold new in the window. The graphics-card refurbished figure and the half-price CPU section use every pair.
- Outliers. Pairs whose not-new price was under 15% or over 120% of the new price are dropped.
- Stores. Open-box offers are Best Buy’s (354 of 383, every TV and graphics card); the rest are almost all ProCam’s open-box lenses and cameras. Refurbished come mostly from Amazon Renewed and Best Buy; used, mostly from camera stores. Category figures need 20 or more pairs.
- Not in the data. Warranty and return terms; whether an item was ever opened. Products with no not-new offer, which are most of them.